A board member asks whether the association needs an audit. Another says the bookkeeper already prepares monthly financial reports. Someone else remembers a threshold in Minnesota law. All three may be talking about different services.
A financial statement prepared by management is not the same as an independent CPA review, and a review is not the same as an audit. Minnesota common interest communities should evaluate the applicable requirements of Minnesota Statutes § 515B.3-121, their governing documents and any owner-approved requirements before deciding which engagement is necessary.
What Is the Difference Between a Compilation, Review and Audit?
Financial statements prepared by management
The bookkeeper or management company may prepare a balance sheet, income statement, budget comparison and supporting schedules. These reports help the board oversee operations, but they do not provide independent CPA assurance.
Compilation
A CPA helps present financial information in statement form. A compilation does not provide an audit opinion or review conclusion.
Review
A CPA performs primarily inquiry and analytical procedures and provides limited assurance that the CPA is not aware of material modifications needed for the statements to conform with the applicable accounting framework.
Audit
An audit involves more extensive procedures and provides reasonable, not absolute, assurance. The auditor expresses an opinion on the financial statements. It typically costs more and requires more documentation than a review.
How Do Minnesota’s Requirements Apply?
Under MCIOA, the annual financial reporting framework is tied to statutory conditions, including the association’s assessment activity, and may also be affected by governing documents and member action. Do not assume that a dollar threshold remembered from an older article or another association automatically applies to yours. Check the currently applicable text of § 515B.3-121, including its exceptions and any applicable effective dates.
For an accurate decision, have the board or CPA confirm:
- Whether the association is subject to the relevant MCIOA provision.
- The correct annual assessment amount and measurement period.
- Whether an independent review is triggered and whether an exception applies.
- Whether the declaration or bylaws require a higher level of assurance.
- Whether an audit is requested by a lender, insurer or another stakeholder.
A review requirement does not automatically mean a full audit is required.
A Twin Cities Example: Why the Assessment Figure Matters
In a 48-unit townhouse association in Woodbury, the board collects regular monthly assessments, then approves a one-time project assessment for siding repairs. Before hiring a CPA, the treasurer should confirm exactly which assessment amounts count under the governing statutory provision, rather than relying only on the annual operating budget.
The board should also ask whether its financial statements are on a cash, modified-cash or accrual basis. A CPA’s engagement letter should identify the accounting framework and the deliverables.
What Should the Board Prepare for the CPA?
- Year-end general ledger and trial balance
- Bank statements and completed reconciliations for every account
- Reserve and operating account schedules
- Assessment billing, collections and delinquency reports
- Vendor invoices and disbursement support
- Loans, CDs and other investment documentation
- Insurance information and significant commitments
- Board minutes and major contract approvals
- Prior-year statements and CPA correspondence
Good records make the engagement more efficient. For the basics of reading monthly reports, see our guide to HOA financial statements. For warning signs that deserve closer attention, read five HOA financial red flags Minnesota boards should not ignore.
Questions to Ask Before Signing a CPA Engagement Letter
Ask what level of service is being provided, what accounting basis will be used, whether tax preparation is included, who will propose year-end adjustments, and when the board will receive the final report. Also confirm who is responsible for providing records and answering follow-up questions.
A common mistake is to approve a quote labeled “year-end financials” without understanding whether it includes any independent assurance.
What to Do Next
Start by putting the issue on the next board agenda, assigning one director or the manager to gather the documents, and documenting the decision and follow-up deadline. Where the question involves interpreting Minnesota law, tax rules, insurance coverage or a disputed owner charge, involve the association’s qualified professional before taking action.
For more practical tools, visit EPMI’s board resources. If your board wants help with consistent financial administration, vendor coordination and homeowner communication, explore professional townhouse and condominium management from Exclusive Property Management Inc..
Ready for fewer surprises and clearer board decisions? Contact Exclusive Property Management Inc. to discuss your Minnesota association’s management needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does every Minnesota HOA need an annual audit?
No. An audit is different from a CPA review. The applicable statute, association documents and other obligations determine what is required.
Can the management company’s bookkeeper perform the independent CPA review?
No. Internal financial preparation does not replace an independent CPA assurance engagement.
Can our HOA voluntarily obtain an audit?
Yes, subject to proper board authority and budget. An audit may be useful when there are material control concerns or other circumstances requiring greater assurance.
Does a CPA review guarantee there is no fraud?
No. A review provides limited assurance and is not designed to detect every fraud or error.
What if our HOA’s governing documents require an audit?
Have counsel or the CPA review the requirement. Governing documents may impose obligations beyond the statutory baseline.